Russell Wilson Is A System Quarterback – Myth or Fact?

All he does is win games.
All he does is win games.

So I am going to weigh in on the Russell Wilson contract issue again.  But I am going to try and look at this from a different perspective.

About six years ago, I wrote an article for the Bleacher Report called The Myth About A System Quarterback.  At the time, I was writing under the pseudonym of Seattle Lion Fan.

According to Wikipedia, a system quarterback is defined as “is an American football quarterback who flourishes under a particular offensive system, specifically one that focuses on passing.”

Under another definition, a system quarterback could be defined as one that is successful but not talented.

I, for one, believe that every quarterback in the NFL is a system quarterback.  Each team has its own system whether they drafted a quarterback that fit the direction the head coach wants or they built a system to exploit the talents of a quarterback.

I think the best example of this was when the Miami Dolphins, then coached by the great Don Shula, took Dan Marino.  Shula made six Super Bowl appearances, going 2-4 in those games.  His teams from 1971, 1972, 1973 and 1982 were all keyed by a run-first offensive strategy, including the undefeated team of 1972.

That all changed when Dan Marino, drafted in 1983 and became the full-time starter in 1984 when he threw for over 5,000 yards and threw 48 touchdowns.  Shula recognized what he had in Marino and built a system around him which in my eyes, makes Marino a system quarterback.

Another great example is Joe Montana.  Bill Walsh needed to find the perfect quarterback to run his West Coast offense and in 1979, Walsh found him in the third round.  Montana, coming out of Notre Dame, was not your prototypical quarterback.  But Walsh kept saying is that “all this kid does is win.”

Four Super Bowl wins in a span of 13 years with San Francisco as well as never losing one puts Montana in a very elite class.  Many, myself included, put him as one of the greatest quarterbacks to have played the game.

In both of these examples, each quarterback fit the system designed by the coaches…one had a system built for him (Marino) and the other was a perfect fit for a system already in place (Montana).

In Pete Carroll’s system, he needed a quarterback that had the capabilities to:

  • Have lots of mobility but still look to throw
  • Take care of the ball on their possessions
  • Make smart and intelligent plays
  • Be the leader on offense
  • Make the big play when needed.

Russell Wilson fills each of these needs very, very well.  How can you argue when all this kid has done in his past three seasons as the Seahawk quarterback is win?

  • Three straight post-season appearances.
  • Two straight Super Bowl appearances (and it should have been two straight wins!).
  • 36 – 11 regular season record over three seasons.
  • Career passing percentage of 98.6 over those three seasons and averaged 100.6 over the last two years.
  • Has not missed a game in those three years.

I truly believe that Russell Wilson is the best fit for this Seahawk offense.  Is there another QB worth a damn that can do better than Wilson at this point?  Tavaris Jackson?  Been tried and he could do no better than 7-9.  Granted he didn’t have Marshawn Lynch as a running back but even with Beast Mode, I doubt he do much better than 9-7.  T-Jack is a turnover machine and checks down way too much.

Wilson fits the system that Carroll has designed.  Wilson needs the Seahawks and the Seahawks need Wilson.  What the question is now is what is the magic number to get the deal done?

The top seven highest paid quarterbacks (listed is guaranteed salaries, not the total contract) according to Sports Cheat Sheet:

  1. Colin Kapernick – San Francisco:  $61 Million
  2. Matt Ryan – Atlanta:  $59 Million
  3. Tom Brady- New England:  $57 Million
  4. Drew Brees – New Orleans:  $55 Million
  5. Tony Romo – Dallas:  $55 Million
  6. Aaron Rodgers – Green Bay:  $54 Million
  7. Jay Cutler – Chicago:  $54 Million

So tell me, out of these seven quarterbacks, which one would you take over Russell Wilson?  If I had to pick, it would most likely be Aaron Rodgers.  Why?  Because he is a 6’2″ version of Russell Wilson…or to be more accurate, Russell is a 5’11” version of Rodgers.

Imagine how successful Rodgers would have been if he had the caliber of running back such as Marshawn Lynch as well as the defense of our beloved Seahawks!  Rodgers would be out of fingers with Super Bowls.  And yet, hardly anyone batted an eyelid when Rodgers signed one of the most lucrative contracts in the NFL.

I agree, you take away Lynch and Russell would be a different QB.  But I believe that he would still be successful because Wilson can adapt to compensate for the loss of a great running game…he would adapt to the changes in the system.

Russell Wilson deserves to be paid as one of the highest paid quarterbacks in the league simply because of what he has shown what he’s done over the past three seasons.  Does he deserve to be the highest paid?  If he can get it, more power to him.  But this is one player the Seahawks cannot say “next man up!” because they don’t have a player of his caliber to take his place.

Pay the man, he deserves it.